Indiana District Court Rejects Preemption Claim Against Indiana

Judge Richard Young of the Southern District of Indiana today granted the state of Indiana’s motion for Summary Judgment in the challenge by E.F. Transit to the state’s denial of E.F. Transit’s transportation services. This case has a long and tortured back story with a previous dismissal for being unripe being reversed by the 7th Circuit earlier…Read More

Supreme Court Sets Oral Argument in the Tennessee Retailers case for January 16, 2019

January 16, 2019 at 11:00 AM EST the Supreme Court of the United States will hear oral argument on the Tennessee Retailers Association matter.  The Court announced this with their release of the January calendar.   (previous post)Fourteen Briefs Filed in Support of Tennessee Wine and Spirits Retailers Association’s Appeal to the Supreme Court Petitioner…Read More

Motion to Dismiss Out of State Wholesaler Challenge to California Wholesaler Law Scheduled for December 21, 2018

The Eastern District of California will hear the Motion to Dismiss filed by the state of California on December 21, 2018.   California wholesaler organizations weighed in with an amicus in support of the state and the plaintiff Orion Wine has filed a brief in opposition to the motion to dismiss. (previous post) Motions to Dismiss Out of…Read More

7th Circuit Reverses and Remands Illinois Retail Shipping Matter

The 7th Circuit finally ruled on the retailer direct shipping case it has had before it for a year.  The 7th Circuit reversed the district court’s grant of the state’s motion to dismiss and remanded this case back to district court for additional fact-finding on the Plaintiff’s Equal Protection and dormant Commerce Clause challenges. I attended the oral…Read More

Michigan Court Enters Stay of Retail Shipping Order Pending Supreme Court Review of TN Case

Because of the pending Supreme Court review of the Byrd v. TN Retailers Association matter, Judge Tarnow granted the state of Michigan’s motion and has issued a stay of his injunction against the Michigan retail shipping law.   In acknowledging the pending Supreme Court matter, the judge noted: “The Court is aware that legislative efforts to bring…Read More